New Formalism

New Formalism Poetry

New Formalist poetry looked to the past. New Formalists, rather than follow in the footsteps of counterculture poetry movements such as Free Verse and Confessional Poetry, wished to follow in the footsteps of formal poets. This meant that New Formalist poetry greatly valued meter, rhyme, stanza rhyming, and even the aesthetic appearance of their poetry. New Formalism poetry was a reaction to the rapidly changing literary styles of the 20th century.

The Poetry Foundations of New Formalism

New Formalists are considered to have emerged in the 1980s and 1990s, but the foundations for the movement were set as early as the late 1960s and early 1970s. In 1968 Lewis Turco, an American poet published The Book of Forms: A Handbook of Poetics (1968), which was a formalist handbook on how to construct poetry.

In the 1970s, many poets such as Robert B. Shaw and Charles Martin began to publish poetry books that were traditional in form and strayed away from popular free verse poetry. In 1980, a magazine called The Reaper was put together by Mark Jarman and Robert McDowell to promote formal poetry. This allowed for New Formalist to become a recognized poetry movement.

The New Formalism Movement

The 20th century saw a lot of diversity and change in American poetry. In the 1920s, poets began to write in free verse such as Ezra Pound and T.S Eliot, and by the 1950s Confessional Poetry made an appearance with poets such as Robert Lowell and Allen Ginsburg. Traditional forms of poetry could still be found such as the poetry of Robert Frost and Anthony Hecht and the New Criticism movement of poetry.

From the 1980s on, New Formalism was established as a literary movement and more New Formalist poetry magazines and books were published. They faced a lot of criticism but the movement went into the mainstream in the 21st century and many poets today still write with a large emphasis on a traditional form.

Characteristics and Elements of New Formalism

Much like architectural plans, New Formalist poets valued structure and form in their poems, pixabay.

New Formalist poetry differed depending on the author, but the main defining feature of a New Formalist poem is the use of structured meter, rhyme, and stanzas.

In this excerpt from Dana Gioia's poem "Pity the Beautiful", we can see a typical New Formalist structure. Gioia places great emphasis on the end rhyme of the second and fourth lines of the poem (dishes, wishes).

New formalists also used common literary devices such as metaphor, enjambment, allusions, and sound devices within a formulaic structure.

New Formalists also preferred to write in narrative structures rather than free verse lyricism. A poetic narrative structure tells a story, with a beginning, a conflict, and a resolution. There will often be a fully developed plot with fully developed characters with narratives.

New Formalist poetry is often written in a narrative structure with a fully developed plot, pixabay.

Literary Criticism: New Formalism

New Formalism has been heavily critiqued by many. In 1985 the Association of Writers and Writing Programs wrote a piece in their May issue stating that New Formalists promoted social conservatism and an elitist sense of capitalism. Many critics, especially those who saw the breakdown of traditional forms as more inclusive to minority writers and audiences, believed New Formalism only supported patriarchal and white supremacist views on literature.

Many New Formalists have spoken out against this criticism. Annie Finch, an American New Formalist Poet, has spoken out against the critique stating that New Formalism can be used to reclaim elitist language by minority groups¹.

Julia Alvarez, a Dominican American New Formalist, believes that using the structured language of the English and Spanish colonizers is a form of rebellion, especially as her poetry focused on what it means to be a Latina woman.

New Formalism was seen as inherently political, with many believing it was for elitist, white populations and against the Free Verse Revolution, however, many New Formalists have pushed back against this notion.

Examples of New Formalism

There are many New Formalist poet examples, pixabay.com

Many New Formalist poet examples include Dana Gioia, X.J. Kennedy, Brad Leithauser, Marilyn Hacker, A. E. Stallings, and Leo Yankevich.

Dana Gioia

Dana Gioia was born in Hawthorne, California in 1950 and became associated with the New Formalist movement in the 1980s. Dana Gioia has written five poetry books, multiple volumes of literary criticism, and many literary anthologies. Gioia has been interviewed by many journals and magazines, and he defends New Formalism.

Brad Leithauser

Brad Leithauser is a New Formalist poet born in 1953 in Detroit, Michigan. Leithauser has written seven poetry collections, many novels, essay collections. He's also edited volumes and an anthology.

A. E. Stallings

A. E. Stallings is a New Formalist poet from Decatur, Georgia, born in 1968. Although considered a New Formalist poet, Stallings is known for creating a grey area within her poems between free verse and formal poetic structures. She applied her classical studies training, incorporating many mythological allusions into her work. Stallings has written countless poetry books and has been awarded many prizes. She was a finalist for a Pulitzer Prize in 2019.

1. 'Giving Back the World its Lost Heart', Able Muse Magazine, Critical Issue May (2002). Interview by R.S. Gwynn.