William Hill Brown

Biography of William Hill Brown

Not much is written about William Hill Brown's short life. William Hill Brown was born in Boston in 1765. He anonymously published his first novel, The Power of Sympathy, at the age of twenty-three. He would go on to write two more novels, Harriot, or the Domestic Reconciliation (1789) and Ira and Isabella (1807), essays, and poems that were posthumously published in Selected Poems and Verse Fables 1784-1793 by William Hill Brown (1982).

Brown was born in colonial Boston. Pixabay.

In 1792, William Hill Brown decided to go study law and moved to North Carolina. Brown settled in Murfreesboro, North Carolina. There, Thomas O'Neill, a merchant he knew, had a shop, and Brown's sister and brother-in-law lived there as well. Brown would begin to study law with General William R. Davie from Halifax, and he spent the last year of his life in North Carolina.

In 1793, Brown became sick with a fever and died shortly after at the age of 27.

Novels by William Hill Brown

William Hill Brown wrote three novels during his lifetime, The Power of Sympathy, Ira and Isabella, and Harriot, or the Domestic Reconciliation. The Power of Sympathy followed the sentimental style of Samuel Richardson, an English novelist credited with developing the Modern English Novel. Hariot, or the Domestic Reconciliation was a romantic tale about a revolutionary soldier. In 1807, another novel by William Hill Brown was published called Ira and Isabella, which is a tale about the power of seduction and incest.

Brown wrote three novels during his lifetime. Pixabay.

William Hill Brown's novels were based on his knowledge of European Literature. He was especially inspired by Samuel Richardson's sentimental novel, Clarissa (1747-8). However, rather than follow the traditions of writing novels set in Britain, Brown's novels are unique for their being set in the American colonies and representing the local conflicts.

His novels were focused on morality. In them, a character or characters are seduced or seducers. This inevitably leads to a tragedy of some sort. Brown wanted to remind his readers of a moral code he felt should be the foundation of American Colonial societies. These moral codes are based on rationality, restraint, and sympathy. In the preface of the Power of Sympathy, Brown writes:

Brown was especially concerned with the young women in his society falling into traps of seduction and involving themselves in scandal. Therefore, his novels have a didactic overtone that is meant to remind and guide the reader on codes of morality.

His novels may have also included taboo topics such as incest for the purpose of capturing a reader's attention. In 18th-century literature, taboo topics would thrill audiences and engage them, which allows Brown's moralistic teachings to be more impactful on the reader.

The Power of Sympathy by William Hill Brown

The Power of Sympathy by William Hill Brown is considered to be the first American novel. It is a Sentimental Novel that uses the epistolary form.

The Power of Sympathy is written in epistolary form. Pixabay.

The novel opens with letters written between Thomas Harrington and Jack Worthy. The reader learns Thomas is in love with Harriot, despite her father's hesitancy and Harriot's resistance. Thomas is determined to make her his lover but Jack warns him to court her properly.

When Thomas and Harriot are married, a friend named Eliza Holmes reveals a shocking truth. Thomas and Harriot are actually step-siblings as they share the same mother, Maria Fawcet. Harriot becomes so upset about the incestuous relationship that she dies of consumption. When Harriot dies, Thomas commits suicide.

Brown wove a moral lesson into the novel. Brown wanted the reader to see that characters that express too much sympathy have fatal consequences while those who are rational, remain alive. Sympathy, in the opinion of Brown, leads to an excess of passion and impulse, which happened to Thomas when he fell in love with Harriot. Therefore, Brown wants the reader to learn that a balance between sympathy and rationality must be found in order to live a successful and moral life.

Impact of William Hill Brown

The Power of Sympathy is considered the first American novel. Pixabay.

When William Hill Brown first anonymously published The Power of Sympathy, the novel was not very successful. Many readers felt unsure about the moral lesson they were supposed to learn at the end of the novel because Brown leaves it up for interpretation. British didactic novels, which most American colonists were used to, always had a clear lesson by the end of the novel. However Brown left the text open, meaning readers must look at all the viewpoints laid out in the story and come to their own conclusions on morality. Brown was simply there as a writer to guide them. For this reason, Brown's writing became a uniquely American style of novel-writing that moved the direction of American literature away from mainly British traditions to independent traditions.

Quotes by William Hill Brown

Here are a few quotes from William Hill Brown's novels that exemplify his work.

Here we see the concept of seduction and its power in Brown's novel Ira and Isabella. The narrator is trying to rationalize his love for Isabella and is being influenced by the power of seduction. He desires her so greatly, that he alludes to Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet (1597) as a source of justification, but the reader can see that he is acting irrationally.

Harriot is writing to her husband/brother Thomas. She is conflicted about the overwhelming emotions she is feeling. On one hand, she knows that she is unable to be with Thomas any longer because he is her brother, incest is illegal, and it's very taboo. On the hand, Harriot still loves Thomas as a lover and feels that the love they had for one another was genuine. The heightened sense of emotion and focus on the emotional conflicts felt by Harriot in this passage exemplify the genre of Sentimental Novels.

Thomas is about to commit suicide after his wife/half-sister Harriot dies in The Power of Sympathy. Suicide would've been seen in Colonial America as an immoral act. However, Thomas is trying to display his "rationality" in thought, and his rationality is clearly marked by the emotional distress her death has had on him. This creates a moral ambiguity that the reader must discern for themselves.