Utopian Fiction

Utopian Fiction Definition

Utopias as mythical places of the past have existed in many different cultures for centuries. From The Greek Golden Age to the German Schlaraffenland, the concept of an ideal, harmonious society is not new. The difference between utopian fiction and utopian myths tends to be that the fiction takes place in an alternative present or the future.

The word utopia comes from ancient Greek and can be translated literally as ‘no place’ or less literally as ‘nowhere’. The Greek for 'good place’ is pronounced almost the same way in English. This pun or play on meaning and words inspired Sir Thomas More, who wrote the first novel of this genre, Utopia, in 1516. At the core of utopian fiction are the questions 'Is nowhere a good place?' and 'Is the ideal society possible?'

Lyman Tower Sargent, a renowned utopian fiction academic, highlighted potential utopian paradoxes, too. Oscar Wilde had a different view on utopias, believing them to drive progress and always provide something new for humanity to aim for.

Whatever the answers to these questions or paradoxes might be, you will find that utopian fiction tends to feature highly detailed imaginary worlds set in a certain time and place, often with an underlying message to share.

Utopian Fiction Characteristics

Although there are differences of opinion on the possibility of actual utopias and a wide range of fictional utopias depicted, some common threads do run through many works. These include:

• Freedom of information is allowed, with censorship and propaganda not featuring at all.
• Creativity, independent thought, and personal freedom are actively promoted.
• A benevolent figurehead or concept unites the citizens without limiting their individuality.
• The population does not live in fear.
• Technology is used to benefit citizens rather than to control them.
• The existence of a harmonious society is featured.
• The natural world is respected.
• Innovation and evolution are encouraged.

Utopian Fiction Examples

There is a wide range of novels in utopian fiction, as this is a broad and not very well-defined genre. Works may include utopian science fiction, post-apocalyptic fiction, adventure, or fantasy. Let's look at the first utopian fiction novel in more detail to better understand the genre's development up to where it is today.

Utopia (1516) by Sir Thomas More is considered the original utopian fiction novel. It depicts a largely peaceful and prosperous society based on an island off South America.

Fig. 1 - This is an example of a utopian setting.

Context

As a statesman, lawyer, writer, and one time Lord Chancellor of England, it is unclear whether More intended Utopia to be a satire or the genuine projection of an ideal society. Or perhaps both.

Many scholars regard his Utopia as a work of pro-Socialist idealism, but many others regard it as a satirical critique of Socialism. Still others view it as a satirical criticism of the existing politics and society that he lived in. It is known that More published many other texts both critiquing and promoting Socialism. It has been suggested that he was perhaps highlighting the difference between the idea and the practice of political and social theories.

Outside of these apparent contradictions, in his time as Lord Chancellor, More was also a persecutor of Protestants, so the religious tolerance of his utopian society is also in contrast to his known reality. Additionally, as a powerful lawyer himself, he magnanimously created a utopia where no lawyers were necessary in his fiction.

Themes

In line with current utopian fiction norms, More goes into great detail in Utopia, creating a unique society. Many of his ideas were revolutionary in his time, especially considering his prominent political role. Some of the most discussed, factual elements of his novel include:

Law

There are no lawyers at all in Utopia. The law has been made extremely simple so that anyone can easily understand what is lawful or unlawful.

Politics and economics

There is also no private land ownership in More’s Utopia. Houses are rotated between citizens and no one locks their doors. Goods are stored in warehouses and distributed on request. Gold and silver are used solely for chamber pots, chains for slaves, and potentially bribing other countries. In addition, More's Utopia has a limit on permitted work hours, free hospitals, and euthanasia is legal.

Religion

All religions are tolerated and there are many religions practiced in Utopia. The only stance that is disapproved of but tolerated is atheism. Priests can marry and widows can become female priests. Divorce is permitted. In contrast, there are severe punishments for pre-marital sex, and women are required to confess their sins to their husbands once a month.

War

War is condemned and viewed as something to be avoided at all costs. Enemies are captured and turned into slaves rather than killed.

Utopian Science Fiction

Closely linked to utopian fiction is utopian science fiction. While utopian fiction deals in a general way with utopias, utopian science fiction usually focuses on ideals of science and technology.

The definitions of what constitutes science fiction are more blurred than those of utopian fiction, but many novels and series have been clearly classified as utopian science fiction. These works tend to feature ideal societies, are often set in the future, and usually depict harmonious, prosperous societies with highly advanced technologies.

Utopian Science Fiction Books

Many utopian science fiction novels are pure utopias, but some are utopias within dystopias. The interplay between dystopias and utopias in science fiction can get a little complex.

Pioneering examples of utopian science fiction include some of HG Well's works such as Men Like Gods (1923).

A few more recent pure utopian science fiction books or series include The Culture Series (1987-2012) by Ian M. Banks and the Commonwealth Saga (2004 - 2010) by Peter F. Hamilton. These series both depict largely peaceful human and humanoid societies that have achieved near immortality, post-scarcity economies and highly advanced technologies used for the betterment of their citizens.

Some science fiction novels that feature utopias within dystopias are Octavia Butler’s The Parable of the Sower (1993). In this dystopian post-apocalyptic novel the protagonist, Lauren invents her own utopian religion, Earthseed.

Aldous Huxley's Brave New World (1932) has also been portrayed as a dystopia with utopian elements. The people in Brave New World are happy and prosperous, but the way that this is achieved is generally what classifies it as a dystopia.

1. Sargent, Lyman Tower, Utopianism: a very short introduction. Oxford University Press, 2010.

2. Oscar Wilde, Concept of Utopia, Man's soul under Socialism, Fortnightly Review, 1891.