New Criticism

New criticism: definition

The definition of new criticism is as follows:

New criticism believes in analysing the value of literary works based only on the text itself, without taking into account the following:

• The author's background or intentions while writing the text

• The reader's emotional or physical response to the text

• The social, economic, political or historical context of the text

• The moral or philosophical importance of the text

Once the context of the text has been removed, the meaning and value of the text should only rely on what is seen on the page. This means focusing the literary study on the text's aesthetic qualities, such as its

• Form
• Structure
• Language and tone
• Literary devices and techniques
• Characterisation
• Symbols and metaphors
• Actual setting (not context)

New criticism: theory

New criticism arose as a literary theory in the 20th century as a response to traditional styles of literary criticism in America that placed more emphasis on the external factors surrounding a text, rather than the text itself. These old literary schools believed that the meaning of the text is reliant on its author's biography, its historical and cultural context and the philosophical or moral importance of the text.

However, New Critics believed that this approach was too distracting, subjective and emotional. They believed that art should be enjoyed simply for art's sake, rather than ascribing a greater socio-political, moral or didactic purpose to the text. Hence they came up with a far more systematic and objective way of studying literary texts.

Intentional Fallacy

New Critics believed that failure to view a text independently can lead to Intentional Fallacy.

The reality is that while interpreting a text, the critic (or reader) has no idea what the author's true intentions were while producing the text. In some cases, the meaning of a text may not live up to the author's intentions, while in others it may be far more complex and meaningful than the author originally intended. Hence, the author's intentions should be of no relevance and should not have any bearing on the meaning of the text.

Affective Fallacy

A similar notion called Affective Fallacy was also introduced by New Critics as something that should be avoided during literary analysis.

Every reader may interpret a text differently, and there is no way a critic can have access to readers' response that is free of personal biases, unified and constant. Therefore, they should not confuse the meaning of a text with the reader's reaction.

New criticism: example

To better understand New criticism, let us apply this style of criticism to analyse a text. For this example, we will be analysing F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel The Great Gatsby (1925).

When viewed in this context, Fitzgerald's novel can be viewed as a criticism of the American Dream in the 1920s. Gatsby's driving force in the novel, his love interest Daisy, represents wealth, sophistication and aristocracy - the very promise of the American Dream. Winning her heart, therefore, represents part of Gatsby's quest to climb the social ladder and chase the American Dream.

Throughout the novel, Gatsby continues to blindly pursue Daisy, resorting to illegal activities to meet her standards. Despite all his efforts, she ultimately chooses her husband and 'old money' social status. Therefore, the relationship between Gatsby and Daisy represents the hollowness of the American Dream that lures honest and ambitious men into craving materialism, easy money, immorality and empty happiness.

However, a new critic would view The Great Gatsby (1925) without paying heed to the social and cultural context of the Jazz Age. When The Great Gatsby is analyzed through a new criticism lens, Gatsby's rise to a self-made businessman, his relationship with Daisy, and his tragic downfall are seen as exactly as what it is; a man's blind pursuit of unrequited love and the sacrifices he is willing to make along the way. Similarly, Gatsby's fixation with recreating his past relationship with Daisy represents the common human condition of longing for unfulfilled dreams and wanting to freeze time to happier, simpler times.

In this analysis, the context of the Jazz Age and the American Dream are removed while deriving the novel's meaning, and the text is seen as a love story gone wrong. Therefore, by viewing the story from the eyes of a New Critic, The Great Gatsby reveals much more about the human condition than acting as socio-political commentary. A New Critic then derives a text's meaning without looking at its context.

New criticism critics

Here are two notable critics who helped form the basis of the new criticism movement in the early 20th century.

Ivor Armstrong Richards (1893-1979)

The work of English critic I. A. Richards greatly contributed to the foundations of new criticism.

In 1929, Richards published Practical Criticism, a book that took a scientific-empirical approach towards literary criticism. He conducted a study where he asked undergraduate students at Cambridge University to analyse 13 poems without giving them contextual details such as their author, date of publication, and historical and cultural background.

The resultant interpretations produced by the pupils demonstrated the depth of meaning that could be derived from literary analyses when looking at the text alone. This established a new methodology for interpreting literary texts, which later became known as new criticism.

T. S. Eliot (1888-1965)

American poet T. S. Eliot greatly influenced the new criticism movement through his critical essays, particularly “Tradition and the Individual Talent” (1917) and “Hamlet and His Problems” (1919).

Fig. 1 - T.S. Eliot,

Importance of new criticism

New criticism certainly allows a far more systematic and objective way of studying literary texts. It ensures that the meaning of the text does not stray too far away from the text itself. The value of a text is in no way overly influenced by assumptions about the author's intentions, the reader's responses, or the historical and cultural context surrounding the work.

However, new criticism also serves a greater purpose. It introduced a style of literary criticism that is democratic in nature. This is because, according to New Critics, anyone with access to and interest in literature has equal power to criticise it. One does not require years of research and a variety of sources about the author's life, historical background, socio-political context etc. to criticise and appreciate literature. All that is needed is the text itself! Therefore, new criticism made literary criticism easier and more accessible.