Square Deal

Square Deal Definition

The term "square deal" was an expression Americans had been using since the 1880s. It meant a fair and honest trade. In a time of monopolies and labor abuses, many Americans felt that they weren't getting a square deal. Labor disputes and strikes had turned into violence and riots during the late nineteenth century, as American workers fought for their interests.

Square Deal Roosevelt

Shortly after becoming President, Roosevelt made "square deal" his catchphrase. Equality and fair play had become themes of his campaigns and acts in office. He applied "square deal" to groups who had often been forgotten, such as Black Americans, when he made a speech noting that he had fought side by side with Black troops in the Cavalry.

During the 1904 presidential election, Roosevelt even published a short book titled A Square Deal for Every American, outlining his views on a variety of topics. Although he never proposed a comprehensive agenda known as the "square deal", like his fifth cousin Franklin Delano Roosevelt would do with the "New Deal", historians later grouped some of Teddy Roosevelt's domestic legislative agenda together as the Square Deal.

Fig. 2. President Roosevelt Coal Strike Political Cartoon.

Anthracite Coal Strike

The Anthracite Coal Strike of 1902 was a turning point for how the federal government dealt with labor and the beginning of the Square Deal. In earlier strikes, the government had mobilized troops only on the side of industrial owners, to break up the destruction of property or to have soldiers perform the work themselves. When a coal strike occurred in the summer of 1902 and continued through October, it was quickly becoming a crisis. Without any legal authority to force a solution, Roosevelt invited both sides to sit down with him and discuss a solution before the nation headed into winter without an adequate supply of the needed heating fuel. For sticking to fairness on both sides, instead of siding with big money, Roosevelt famously stated that the outcome he helped mediate was "a square deal for both sides."

Anthracite Coal Strike Commission

Roosevelt appealed to the operators of the coal facilities and the leader of the union to come to an agreement out of patriotism, but the best he got was the operators agreeing to a federal commission to mediate the dispute. When filling the seats agreed to by the operators, Roosevelt subverted the operators' idea to appoint an "eminent sociologist" to the commission. He filled the spot with a labor representative and adding in a Catholic priest, as most of the strikers were of Catholic faith.

The strike finally ended on October 23, 1902. The commission detected that some union members had committed violence and intimidation against strikebreakers. It also found that wages were low. The committee decided to create a board to settle disputes between labor and management, as well settling the hour and wage disagreements at the halfway point between what the union and management had each sought.

Fig. 3. Roosevelt Visits Yosemite National Park.

Square Deal's Three C's

Historians have used the "Three C's" to describe the elements of the Square Deal. They are consumer protection, corporate regulation, and conservationism. As a Progressive Republican, Roosevelt sought to protect the public from abuses of corporate power. Fairness is the root of many of his policies. These policies were not aimed at simply opposing the interests of businesses, but it tackled the ways big businesses of the era were able to have unfair and overwhelming power over the public good. He supported both unions and issues that businesses advocated for, such as lower taxes.

Consumer Protection

In 1906, Roosevelt supported two bills that protected outraged consumers from dangerous corner cutting by corporations. The Meat Inspection Act regulated meat packing companies who had been known to sell rotting meat, preserved in dangerous chemicals, as food to unknowing consumers. The problem had gotten so out of hand that American soldiers had died as a result of tainted meat sold to the army. The Pure Food and Drug Act provided for similar inspections and requirements on labeling to be applied to a broader range of foods and drugs in the United States.

Corporate Regulation

Through the Elkins Act in 1903 and Hepburn Act in 1906, Roosevelt pushed for greater regulation of corporations. The Elkins Act took away rail companies' ability to provide rebates on shipping to other large corporations, opening up increased competition by smaller companies. The Hepburn Act allowed the government to regulate railroad prices and even audit their financial records. In addition to passing these acts, the Attorney General went after monopolies, even breaking up the massive Standard Oil.

Conservationism

Trained as a biologist and known for his love of the outdoors, Roosevelt fought to protect America's natural resources. Over 230,000,000 acres of land received protection under his administration. As president, he was even known to go off for weeks at a time exploring the nation's wilderness. In total, he accomplished the following protections:

• 150 national forests
• 51 federal bird reserves
• 4 national game preserves,
• 5 national parks
• 18 national monuments

Fig. 4. Political Cartoon Showing Republican Fear of the Square Deal.

Square Deal History

Having come to power the result of an assassin's bullet in 1902, Roosevelt did not have to seek election as president until 1904. His initial agenda was extremely popular, and he won the 1904 election in a landslide victory. By his second term, his agenda had moved further than many in his party were comfortable with. Ideas like a federal income tax, campaign finance reform, and eight-hour work days for federal employees failed to find the necessary support.

Square Deal Significance

The effects of the square deal changed the country. Unions gained a strength that resulted in large gains for the average American's standard of living. The limits on corporate power and protections for workers, consumers, and the environment were enormous and inspired later actions. Many of the issues he advocated for but could pass were later picked up by Democratic Presidents Woodrow Wilson and Franklin Delano Roosevelt.