Effects of Migration

Political Effects of Migration

Migration is controlled by governments through policies and laws. Immigration laws are rules set by a government on who is allowed in and for how long. These laws can fluctuate depending on the local political climate or world events, providing little to no guarantees for migrants.

Fig. 1 - A protest in DC against President Trump's "travel ban" in January 2017; the US has admitted fewer immigrants and refugees in the last few years due to this policy

Immigration policy can influence who gets elected in some countries. People may believe immigration has positive or negative effects on their communities or on the economy. Some politicians or political parties use their immigration policy to gain votes or support for more open or more restrictive immigration laws.

Examples of the Political Effects of Migration

Examples of the political effects of migration include Japan and Canada's immigration policies. There are major differences in their immigration policies due to history, politics, and social acceptance.

Limited Immigration Policy in Japan

Japan has a very limited migration policy. Due to its geographic distance from other countries and decades of self-imposed isolation, immigration and integration of immigrants are limited. As a result, there are very few highly-skilled immigrants that apply to voluntarily migrate. With low migration rates, immigrants have a limited political effect on Japan.

Immigration policy in Japan may soon change, however, as the elderly population continues to grow and birth rates remain low. This will create issues for Japan, as there aren't enough people to take care of the elderly, as well as to work and pay taxes. Already, there is some debate about changing immigration laws to help with this transition.

Expansive Immigration in Canada

Canada has a highly flexible immigration policy, with one of the highest ratios of foreign-born people in all Western countries. This is due to historically open immigration policies, politicians, and voters. Most of the migration growth is in or around larger cities, with many migrants filling job market needs. Canada has been called the most welcoming country in the world for immigrants, with the majority applying coming from India, China, and the Philippines.

Economic Effects of Migration

There are both positive and negative effects of migration. For forced migrants such as asylum seekers and refugees, there can be some negative economic effects. Upfront costs on housing, education, and transportation must be provided by governments. If these costs are not planned for, they can put a strain on local economies, increase social tension, and lead to negative political effects.

However, high, medium, and low-skilled workers are typically in demand in most of the countries to which they voluntarily migrate. Migrants can take up unfilled jobs while providing unique expertise and insight. Limiting immigration can create greater issues in the economy, as positions may remain empty and hurt businesses.

Fig. 2 - President Biden visits an embassy in Beijing while people wait for their visas

Migration is key in filling many jobs in different parts of the world. This is because local populations may not have provided the education or training for some jobs and an urgent need is present. However, this can also negatively affect countries with high amounts of emigration.

Remittances

Remittances are a private transfer of money from a migrant worker to their family or community in their home country. The amount of remittances is growing globally, along with migration. The main sources of remittances come from workers living in the US, Russia, and Saudi Arabia while India, China, and Mexico are the top recipients of remittances globally. Although it makes up a small percentage of their GDP, some countries heavily rely on remittances to keep their economies running.

Brain Drain Problem

Brain drain occurs when countries lose high-skilled, quality workers to another country that offers better pay or higher quality of life for their labor. This can be a problem as the absence of highly-skilled workers in their home countries can leave jobs unfilled and reduce their advantages in some markets.

Countries experiencing high emigration rates of high-skilled workers would need to investigate the causes. There are several possible reasons which can range from low wages, poor benefits, or unfavorable working conditions. This may lead to major changes in some economic sectors of countries, as they need to adjust incentives to keep workers.

Social Effects of Migration

Cultural differences between original residents and migrants can bring up issues for local communities and governments. Integration, the process of uniting people from different countries, is a difficult task for governments and communities alike. Immigrants must learn new rules, customs, and possibly language to be able to communicate and make bonds in their new countries or places of origin. Unfortunately, sometimes these differences are so great that they can lead to conflict and protests.

Fig. 3 - Diversity in the workplace. Migrants bring in new ideas and perspectives

There are also positive effects of migration on society. The introduction of a new culture can also bring in new ideas, methods, and perspectives. This can enrich the living experience for everyone and provide insight into another person's culture. For instance, almost all high schools and universities in the US have some form of student exchange program. This is due to values placed on new and different perspectives.

Effects of Migration on Globalization

Migration is one of the key drivers of globalization. There is evidence of new complexities in the amount, type, and origins of immigrants around the world. Technology and communication advancements have made it easier and more possible for people to move. In Czaika and Haas' article on the Globalization of Migration, they have found that costs are lower for both travel and communication, and migrant networks can remain intact despite distance.³ Combined with increased education and awareness of opportunities, people's desire to migrate has also increased.

Although people are physically migrating, so are ideas, knowledge, and networks. This fuels globalization, interconnecting countries further at a social and cultural level as well. With higher rates of migration than ever before, globalized growth will continue at the same rate.