What are the primary components required to establish a Law of Trusts in the UK?

The primary components to establish a Law of Trusts in the UK are: declaration of the trust, identification of the property, beneficiaries, and the trustee(s). Additionally, trust purpose must be clearly defined and lawful.

What are the main duties of a trustee under the Law of Trusts in the UK?

The main duties of a trustee in the UK are to act in the best interest of all beneficiaries, safeguard the trust's assets, act impartially between beneficiaries, comply with the terms of the trust and invest trust assets prudently.

What are the implications of breach of trust under the Law of Trusts in the UK?

Breach of trust in the UK can lead to personal liability for any loss the trust suffers, reputational damage, disenfranchisement or removal as a trustee. Moreover, in severe cases, it can result in criminal charges such as fraud or embezzlement.

How can the Law of Trusts be used for estate planning in the UK?

The Law of Trusts in the UK can be used for estate planning by creating a Trust in a will or separately. This allows for the management of assets during life and after death, mitigating inheritance tax liability, and providing for minor or vulnerable beneficiaries.

Who can be appointed as beneficiaries under the Law of Trusts in the UK?

Under UK law, any individual or legal entity, such as a company or charity, can be appointed as a beneficiary in a trust. Even pets can be indirectly benefited through a trust, though they can't be direct beneficiaries.

How do Trusts play a part under the legal framework?

Trusts are a relationship created at the directive of an individual, where one party holds the property rights to assets for the benefit of another party. It's enforced through legislation, case law, and principles that define the roles of the trust, trustee, and beneficiaries, along with their rights and responsibilities.

What is one of the legal remedies available to beneficiaries in instances of breach of trust?

Some of the legal remedies include repayment/compensation for losses, reversal of a wrongful transaction, removal and replacement of the trustee, and half or full indemnity from the trustee’s own property.

What are the three core elements of Trust Law?

The three core elements of Trust Law are the Trustor (the person who creates the trust), the Trustee (the person who manages the trust), and the Beneficiary (the person who benefits from the trust).

What is the role of a trustee in the Law of Trusts?

A trustee's role is to hold and manage assets for the benefit of another. They are responsible for maintaining records, managing and investing trust assets, and making appropriate distributions to beneficiaries.

What is the significance of the historical development of Trust Law?

Trust Law originated during the 12th century Crusades and has evolved over centuries to meet societal needs. The Restatement of the Law of Trusts, especially in the United States, helped to clarify and simplify its principles, influencing global trust law.

What are Testamentary Trusts and when do they come into effect?

Testamentary Trusts are formed based on directions in a person's will and they come into effect only after the trustor’s death.

Law Of Trusts: Breach, History & Types

Law Of Trusts

Delve into the complexities of the Law of Trusts, from its critical elements to its historical evolution. Grasp the extensive range of Trust types under the British legal system and understand how to handle the tricky terrain of trust law breaches. This thorough exploration provides a comparative analysis of different trust types, and a comprehensive look into the repercussions faced when a trust law is breached. Detailed case studies present real-world scenarios, aiding you to apply these concepts practically and to formulate informed decisions about trusts.

Get started

Understanding the Law of Trusts

The Law of Trusts is a complex but important area of law. A trust, in a legal sense, is a relationship created at the directive of an individual, in which one party holds the property rights to assets for the benefit of another party. The Law of Trusts is governed by various principles, established through centuries of case law and legislation.

The Law of Trusts describes the legal framework for creating, executing, and managing trusts. This involves legislation, case law, and principles defining the role of the trust, trustee, beneficiaries, and the legal responsibilities and rights attached.

Core Elements of Trust Law

There are three core elements in Trust Law you should always keep in mind: the Trustor, the Trustee and the Beneficiary.

The Trustor: The person who creates the trust
The Trustee: The person who holds and manages the property on trust
The Beneficiary: The person who is to enjoy the benefit of the trust

The Role of Trustee in the Law of Trusts

One of the most significant components in the Law of Trusts is the role and the duties of the trustee. The trustee is legally obliged to manage the trust in the best interest of the beneficiaries.

A trustee is a person or organisation, who holds and manages assets for the benefit of another. A trustee's responsibilities include, but are not limited to: maintaining records, managing and investing trust assets, and making appropriate distributions to beneficiaries.

Importance of Beneficiary under Trust Law

The beneficiary is a crucial figure in the Law of Trusts as they are the person or persons, who receive the benefits from the trust.

Let's consider an example. A parent sets up a trust for their child's education. In this scenario, the parent is the trustor, the bank appointed as the trustee is responsible for managing the school fees, and the child is the beneficiary who receives the direct benefit of the trust in form of education.

The History of Trust Law

The concept of trusts dates back centuries, with some of the earliest instances found in English law. Trust law has evolved over time to meet the changing needs and demands of society.

Development of Common Law of Trusts

Trusts originated in England during the Crusades of the 12th century. Over centuries, common law of trusts has seen considerable changes, with a focus on clarifying the roles, duties and obligations related to trusts.

The Impact of Restatement of the Law of Trusts

The Restatement of the Law of Trusts has greatly influenced modern trust law. These policies sought to clarify and simplify the principles of trust law, making them more accessible and understandable.

Interestingly, the Restatement of the Law of Trusts in the United States has been particularly influential to trust law globally, shaping legislation in many other jurisdictions.

Types of Trusts under British Legal System

In the British Legal System, there are multiple types of trusts that cater to different needs and situations, each with their unique features. They provide flexibility and allow for a high degree of personalisation based on the trustor's wishes and the beneficiary's needs.

Distinct Types of Trusts under Law

An understanding of the types of trusts under law can better equip you to decide which type is most appropriate for your situation. Trusts can be categorised in several ways, including the method of creation, flexibility, and the time they come into effect.

Two key categories to understand are Express Trusts and Implied Trusts. Express Trusts are intentionally created by the trustor, whereas Implied Trusts emerge as a result of the trustor's circumstances or conduct, even if they didn't intend to create a trust.

Here is a basic comparison of the main types of trusts:

Trust Type	Description
Express Trusts	Trusts that are clearly and intentionally established by the trustor.
Implied Trusts	Trusts that are not explicitly created, but which are inferred by law from the circumstances or behavior of the trustor.
Constructive Trusts	Trusts imposed by law to rectify a situation where someone has acquired legal title to property in an unfair manner.
Resulting Trusts	Trusts that arise when a person makes a payment and law assumes they did not intend a gift, creating a presumption of a resulting trust to the payer.

Revocable vs. Irrevocable Trusts: A Comparative Analysis

The difference between revocable and irrevocable trusts is a fundamental distinction in trust law. As their names suggest, the main difference concerns the ability to amend or terminate the trust after it has been created.

Revocable Trusts: These trusts may be altered or cancelled, wholly or in part, by the trustor during their lifetime. However, after the trustor’s death, the trust becomes irrevocable.

Irrevocable Trusts: These trusts, once established, cannot be altered, amended or rescinded in any way without the beneficiaries granting their permission. They offer more robust protection of assets and potential tax advantages, but at the cost of flexibility.

Testamentary vs. Living Trusts: Understanding the Difference

Another critical component in understanding trusts is the difference between testamentary and living trusts, which refers to when the trust comes into effect.

Testamentary Trusts: These trusts are formed based on directions given in a person's will, and they come into effect only after the trustor’s death.

Living Trusts: These (also known as inter-vivos trusts) come into effect during the trustor's lifetime. It can be further classified as either revocable or irrevocable.

Picture this: Your grandmother wants to leave her house to you, but only when you turn 30. She puts the house in a testamentary trust, with directions in her will for the trust to be created after her death. Until you turn 30, the trust property (the house), is managed by a trustee. After you turn 30, the trustee transfers the house to you, the beneficiary. Thus, a testamentary trust ensures that your grandmother's wishes are carried out exactly as she intended.

Did you know? Living trusts can bypass the probate process entirely. Probate is the legal process of validating a will, paying off debts and distributing property according to the will. This means the trust assets can be distributed to the beneficiaries faster and without the expenses of probate.

Dealing with Breach of Trust Law

In the realm of the Law of Trusts, an intentional or unintentional deviation from the set duties of a trustee leading to damage or potential harm can be considered a breach of trust. Dealing with these infringements involves partaking good judgement and lawful recourse.

Identifying Breach of Trust in Law

In dealing with the Law of Trusts, it's crucial for you to learn how to correctly identify a breach of trust. A breach can occur when a trustee doesn't follow the duty imposed upon them, either intentionally or unintentionally.

Breach of Trust occurs when a trustee, who is legally obligated to manage and utilise the trust property under specific limitations and for the beneficiaries' benefits, fails to do so.

To accurately identify a breach of trust, it's beneficial to understand the instances that are recognised as such under the law:

Improper delegation of duties or powers
Misappropriation or misuse of the trust's funds or assets
Failing to protect and preserve the trust's assets
Failing to act impartially between beneficiaries
Failure to comply with the terms of the trust

If a trustee decided to loan trust property to a friend as a favour, ignoring the fact that the trust expressly forbade loans, this would constitute a breach of trust. The trustee has clearly disregarded the trust's terms and potentially jeopardised trust property.

Legal Remedies for Breach of Trust

The law provides various legal remedies to beneficiaries in instances of breach of trust. If you believe the trustee of a trust has breached their responsibilities, it's pivotal to understand the available legal recourse.

Available remedies include:

Repayment/compensation for losses incurred due to the breach
Reversal of a wrongful transaction
Removal and replacement of the trustee
Half or full indemnity from the trustee’s own property

A common legal remedy for breach of trust is a compensation order, where the court compels the defaulting trustee to compensate the trust for any loss suffered as a result of the breach. The amount usually corresponds to what the trust would have achieved had the breach not occurred. The court may also order a reversal of any transactions completed in breach of trust, reverting the situation back to the original state.

Case Studies Reflecting Breach of Trust Law

Looking at real-life cases can help you better understand how breach of trust law is applied. Here are a few examples of noteworthy cases:

In a classic British case, Re Vickery (1931), a trustee invested in second mortgages instead of first mortgages, breaching their duty of prudent investment. The court ordered the trustee to reimburse the trust property for the difference between what was actually made and what a prudent investment would have earned.

Another compelling case includes Armitage v Nurse (1998), where the Court of Appeal held that except in instances of blatant dishonesty, a trustee could be exempted from liability for negligence or breach of duty.

In Bartlett v Barclays Bank Trust (1980), the trustees were held responsible for not properly monitoring a company within the trust property. It sent a powerful message that trustees have a continuing duty to supervise and intervene if necessary, even when dealing with company directors.

Law Of Trusts - Key takeaways

The Law of Trusts is the legal framework that defines the creation, execution, and management of trusts. It involves legislation, case law, and principles that establish the roles of the trust, trustee, beneficiaries, and their legal rights and responsibilities.
Three core elements of Trust Law: the Trustor - the one who creates the trust, the Trustee - the one who manages the trust property, and the Beneficiary - the one who benefits from the trust.
The development of the Common Law of Trusts originated in England and has evolved over centuries with a focus on clarifying roles and obligations related to trusts. The Restatement of the Law of Trusts, specifically in the United States, has greatly influenced modern trust law globally.
There are various types of trusts in law, including Express Trusts, Implied Trusts, Constructive Trusts, and Resulting Trusts. These trusts are understood and distinguished based on the method of their creation, their flexibility, the time they come into effect, and other unique features.
A Breach of Trust occurs when a trustee fails to follow the limitations and duties imposed on them under the trust law. This can include improper delegation of duties or powers, misuse of trust property, failure to protect and preserve the trust assets, and failure to comply with terms of the trust. Legal remedies for breach of trust may include compensation for losses, reversal of wrongful transactions, and removal of the trustee.

Law Of Trusts

StudySmarter Editorial Team