Explanations 
Flashcards 
StudySmarter AI 
Notes 
Study Plans 
Study Sets 
Exams 
Magazine 
Find a job 
Mobile App 
Jump to a key chapter
Externalism Definition Philosophy
Externalism in philosophy is a fascinating concept that explores the relationship between a person's mind and the external world. It contrasts with the idea that all mental states are determined internally. Externalism proposes that some aspects of our thoughts, knowledge, or meaning are influenced or determined by the environment and context we interact with.
What is Externalism?
Externalism is a philosophical doctrine that argues certain aspects of the mind, such as beliefs, knowledge, or meanings of words, depend not only on internal states but also on external factors. This idea is particularly influential in the field of epistemology and the philosophy of language. In essence, externalism challenges the view that everything about the mind is determined by internal physical states alone.
To better understand externalism, consider these key points:
- It asserts that the external environment plays a crucial role in shaping mental states.
- The context in which thoughts occur influences what thoughts are.
- Externalism is often contrasted with internalism, which holds that mental states are only internally determined.
Externalism: A philosophical view suggesting that the mind and mental states are influenced or determined by factors outside the individual, such as the environment and social context.
Imagine you're holding a glass of water. According to externalism, your understanding of what ‘water’ means isn't just based on your internal concepts but also involves external factors like the chemical structure of water (H2O) and the context in which you learned the term.
Philosophical Externalism
Externalism in philosophy is crucial for understanding how mental states relate to the external world. Whether discussing meanings of words or the nature of belief, externalism introduces an interactionist perspective, contrasting purely internalist viewpoints.
What is Externalism?
Externalism suggests that our thoughts, meanings, and knowledge are partly determined by factors outside of ourselves. This includes the surrounding environment and our interactions within it.
Here are some aspects to consider:
- The environment's influence on belief formation.
- Language and meaning that rely on societal context.
- The steady contrast with internalism, highlighting the exclusive reliance on internal factors.
Externalism: A view in philosophy proposing that mental states are not solely dictated by internal factors but are influenced by the external world and context.
Consider the term 'water.' In an externalist perspective, understanding 'water' requires recognizing its external defining characteristics like H2O. Without this external recognition, the concept may remain incomplete.
Diving deeper into externalism, we find its implications stretch across various philosophical fields. For instance, in epistemology, it suggests that knowing something is not just about internal evidence but also about how this evidence relates to the external world. In philosophy of language, it challenges the notion that words carry meaning only internally, arguing instead for a socially constructed context.
| Domain | Internalism | Externalism |
| Belief | Internal justification | External factors like context |
| Language | Internal association | Societal and contextual influence |
Recent debates explore the balance between internal and external contributions to defining knowledge and understanding in the externalism realm.
Externalism vs Internalism
The philosophical debate between Externalism and Internalism centers on how mental states are determined in relation to the external world. Understanding this contrast is vital for grasping different approaches to the mind-body problem, linguistics, and epistemology.
Defining Internalism and Externalism
Internalism argues that all facets of our mental states, such as beliefs and meanings, are solely determined by internal factors, such as brain states or personal reflections. Conversely, Externalism posits that factors outside one’s subjective experience—like physical environment and social interactions—play a significant role.
Here's a succinct comparison:
| Internalism | Externalism |
| Focuses on internal, subjective experiences. | Emphasizes external, contextual factors. |
| Beliefs are independently formed. | Beliefs are influenced by surroundings. |
Internalism: A philosophical view that mental states are determined solely by an individual's internal states, independent of the external environment.
Consider the belief that it is raining. From an internalist viewpoint, this belief is validated through internal perceptions and sensations. However, from an externalist perspective, its validation may also depend on social and environmental cues, like using weather reports or seeing others with umbrellas.
The implications of adopting an externalist or internalist viewpoint extend into various branches of philosophy:
- In epistemology, the debate affects how we justify knowledge claims—whether knowledge needs connections to the external world or can be internally justified.
- In ethics, it can influence how moral truths are perceived—whether through internal conviction or external societal norms.
- In the philosophy of language, meanings of words might be seen as contingent on usage within a community rather than individual understanding alone.
Understanding these perspectives helps in analyzing complex topics like consciousness, belief systems, and even artificial intelligence.
Epistemic Externalism
Epistemic Externalism is a branch of philosophical externalism focused on the justification and acquisition of knowledge. It examines how external factors contribute to our understanding and the validation of belief systems, offering a contrast to traditional internalist approaches.
Externalism Explained
In epistemology, Externalism asserts that the justification for beliefs can extend beyond one's internal cognitive processes. This contrasts with internalism, where knowledge justification lies entirely within one's mental state. According to externalists, factors like the reliability of sensory perception and the social environment contribute significantly to what we know.
Here's how Externalism differs from Internalism:
- Dependence on Context: Externalism emphasizes the influence of context and external factors on justifying beliefs.
- Reliability: An externalist might argue that a belief is justified if it emerges from a dependable cognitive process.
- Connection to Truth: For externalism, a true belief is more likely when one interacts properly with the environment and acquires information from reliable sources.
Epistemic Externalism: A theory in epistemology asserting that knowledge can be justified by external factors such as environmental interaction and social communication, rather than solely internal reasoning.
Suppose you believe the weather is sunny because you see the sun through your window. An internalist might argue your belief is only justified by your mental recognition of sunlight. However, an externalist would consider additional factors such as the reliability of your eyesight or even the weather report you watched on the news.
Externalism can be critical in fields like artificial intelligence, where decision-making relies on external data.
externalism - Key takeaways
- Externalism Definition Philosophy: Externalism in philosophy is a doctrine that argues mental states, such as beliefs and meanings, are influenced by external factors like environment and context.
- Philosophical Externalism: Highlights the interaction between mental states and external world, emphasizing influence from social and environmental contexts.
- Externalism vs Internalism: Externalism posits that mental states are influenced by external factors, while internalism argues that they are determined solely by internal states.
- Externalism Explained: Involves analyzing how context, social interactions, and reliable processes justify beliefs, contrasting with internal cognitive justification.
- Epistemic Externalism: A subfield of externalism focusing on how external factors justify knowledge, influencing epistemology by looking beyond internal cognitive processes.
- Externalism in Cognitive Science: Examines how external data and interaction with the environment are integrated into cognitive processes and decision-making, impacting fields such as AI.
Learn faster with the 12 flashcards about externalism
Sign up for free to gain access to all our flashcards.
Frequently Asked Questions about externalism
About StudySmarter
StudySmarter is a globally recognized educational technology company, offering a holistic learning platform designed for students of all ages and educational levels. Our platform provides learning support for a wide range of subjects, including STEM, Social Sciences, and Languages and also helps students to successfully master various tests and exams worldwide, such as GCSE, A Level, SAT, ACT, Abitur, and more. We offer an extensive library of learning materials, including interactive flashcards, comprehensive textbook solutions, and detailed explanations. The cutting-edge technology and tools we provide help students create their own learning materials. StudySmarter’s content is not only expert-verified but also regularly updated to ensure accuracy and relevance.
Learn more